
| 1875 | William M. Smith* |
| 1876 | H.H. Hatch* |
| 1877 | H.H. Hatch* |
| 1878 | D.T. Smith* |
| 1879 | H.H. Hatch* |
| 1880 | H.H. Hatch* |
| 1881 | H.H. Hatch* |
| 1882 | H.H. Hatch* |
| 1883 | H.H. Hatch* |
| 1884 | William B. Loveland/ O.K. Beeman* |
| 1885 | O.K. Beeman* |
| 1886 | H.H. Hatch* |
| 1887 | H.H. Hatch* |
| 1888 | CS Thompson* |
| 1889 | EJ Tyler* |
| 1890 | EJ Tyler* |
| 1891 | CA Miller* |
| 1892 | FB Miller* |
| 1893 | T Lee* |
| 1894 | Algernon D Hart* |
| 1895 | LC Henry* |
| 1896 | EJ Tyler* |
| 1897 | John H Elwell* |
| 1898 | F Moore* |
| 1899 | F Moore* |
| 1900 | Frank S Hart* |
| 1901 | LB Hughes* |
| 1902 | FB Miller* |
| 1903 | Frank S Hart* |
| 1904 | Frank S Hart* |
| 1905 | Frank S Hart* |
| 1906 | Frank S Hart* |
| 1907 | Frank S Hart* |
| 1908 | Frank S Hart* |
| 1909 | Frank S Hart* |
| 1910 | George E Minich* |
| 1911 | George E Minich* |
| 1912 | RP Flick* |
| 1913 | RP Flick* |
| 1914 | HH Michiner* |
| 1915 | RP Flick* |
| 1916 | Frank S Hart* |
| 1917 | George E Minich* |
| 1918 | FE Benson* |
| 1919 | H D Walker* |
| 1920 | H R Dana* |
| 1921 | Dio D Reynolds* |
| 1922 | A Y Osmer* |
| 1923 | D S Lillibridge* |
| 1924 | S B Rice* |
| 1925 | W R Jones* |
| 1926 | E H Lillibridge* |
| 1927 | E A Bowles* |
| 1928 | W S Brockway* |
| 1929 | J H Hyde Sr.* |
| 1930 | Alex Greig* |
| 1931 | C Erdice* |
| 1932 | L B Stevens* |
| 1933 | J H Hyde Jr.* |
| 1934 | Alvin E Bosley* |
| 1935 | E D Haughton* |
| 1936 | C P Hyde* |
| 1937 | Wayne E Wolcott* |
| 1938 | L E Bates* |
| 1939 | J C Viney* |
| 1940 | Wilbur C French* |
| 1941 | C J Hyde* |
| 1942 | John R Pflug* |
| 1943 | Lewellyn G Jewell* |
| 1944 | R J Galpin* |
| 1945 | Neal Cox* |
| 1946 | Bernard L Moore* |
| 1947 | W D Cole* |
| 1948 | I K Strock* |
| 1949 | H E Latimer* |
| 1950 | J D Farmer* |
| 1951 | H R Hyden* |
| 1952 | Harry E Munson* |
| 1953 | James C Booth* |
| 1954 | Harlan W Hurd* |
| 1955 | W F Hickox* |
| 1956 | Robert E Hyden |
| 1957 | C A Manowin* |
| 1958 | Carroll E Woodford* |
| 1959 | Hans F Schlacht* |
| 1960 | W A Hyde* |
| 1961 | Dorsey H Kempke* |
| 1962 | Elwin J Dale |
| 1963 | James D Farmer Jr |
| 1964 | William C Horton |
| 1965 | R H Doan* |
| 1966 | Clarence E Ohl* |
| 1967 | Roger E French |
| 1968 | P T Flitcraft* |
| 1969 | D E Nims* |
| 1970 | Archie E Eggleston* |
| 1971 | John Streitferdt |
| 1972 | C C Snyder* |
| 1973 | Melvin M Smith |
| 1974 | Armin C Bailey* |
| 1975 | A L Brockway* |
| 1976 | Forrest B Woods* |
| 1977 | Robert A Davison |
| 1978 | Wayne C Stroup* |
| 1979 | RD Palette* |
| 1980 | Harmon R Ridings* |
| 1981 | Ronnie C Rennolds* |
| 1982 | Robert E Hodge* |
| 1983 | V H Ahart* |
| 1984 | Robert H Hill |
| 1985 | Dio R Rennolds* |
| 1986 | George R Lynch |
| 1987 | Mike A Rennolds |
| 1988 | Virgil McCartney* |
| 1989 | John A Jackson* |
| 1990 | H G Jackson* |
| 1991 | Carl L Miller |
| 1992 | James E Richards |
| 1993 | Cary C Carter |
| 1994 | Richard D Biles |
| 1995 | Patrick G Yoder |
| 1996 | Charles W Allison |
| 1997 | Glenn R Williams |
| 1998 | Keith Sawyer |
| 1999 | Richard Cribbs |
| 2000 | Karl H. Gerlt* |
| 2001 | Howard I Walters |
| 2002 | Richard Selep |
| 2003 | Paul Hodge |
| 2004 | Raymond Williams |
| 2005 | George Perich |
| 2006 | Glenn Wilson Sr. |
| 2007 | Charles W. Reep |
| 2008 | William J. Stear |
