| Martha's Vineyard Lodge | Oriental Lodge | |
|---|---|---|
| Joseph T. James | 1860 1861 1862 |
|
| Benjamin Clough | 1863 1864 |
|
| Henry Bradley | 1865 | |
| 1866 | John Pierce | |
| William Leach | 1867 | |
| J. Weldon Holmes | 1868 | |
| William Leach | 1869 | |
| Stephen A. Thomas | 1870 | Jeremiah Pease |
| 1871 | ||
| 1872 | ||
| Henry Beetle | 1873 | |
| 1874 | ||
| 1875 | ||
| William Leach | 1876 | |
| Andrew (William?) Hillman | 1877 | |
| 1878 | ||
| Matthew L. Smith | 1879 | Zenas D. Linton |
| 1880 | ||
| R.W. Gilbert L. Smith | 1881 | |
| 1882 | Jason L. Dexter | |
| 1883 | ||
| 1884 | ||
| 1885 | Joseph W. Donaldson | |
| 1886 | ||
| 1887 | ||
| Cyrus H. Pease | 1888 | |
| 1889 | ||
| 1890 | ||
| John H. Crowell | 1891 | David J. Barney |
| Charles F. Chadwick | 1892 | |
| R.W. Gilbert L. Smith | 1893 | |
| William W. Niefert | 1894 | |
| 1895 | Jason L. Dexter | |
| William D. Harding | 1896 | |
| 1897 | Richard D. Shute | |
| R.W. Gilbert L. Smith | 1898 | |
| 1899 | Francis P. Vincent | |
| Herbert N. Hinckley | 1900 | |
| 1901 | Jason L. Dexter | |
| Henry W. McLellan | 1902 | James C. Sandsbury |
| 1903 | ||
| R.W. William J. Look | 1904 | |
| 1905 | John E. White | |
| 1906 | Elmer E. Landers | |
| 1907 | ||
| Alvin H. Cleveland | 1908 | Thomas A. Dexter |
| 1909 | ||
| Abbott L. Baker | 1910 | Joseph K. Sylvia |
| 1911 | ||
| R.W. Ulysses E. Mayhew | 1912 | Charles B. Osborn |
| 1913 | ||
| Norman Johnson | 1914 | James C. Sandsbury |
| 1915 | Thomas A. Dexter | |
| Lester H. Bumpus | 1916 | Herbert C. Pease |
| Dana C. Swift | 1917 | Manuel Swartz Roberts |
| 1918 | Joseph K. Sylvia | |
| Alton C. Tuckerman | 1919 | Frank Norton, Jr. |
| R.W. Stephen Carey Luce, Jr. | 1920 | Alfred A. Averill |
| Abbott L. Baker | 1921 | LeRoy W. Vose |
| Fred K. Snow | 1922 | |
| 1923 | Arthur B. Hillman | |
| George Churhill | 1924 | Arthur W. Davis |
| 1925 | John R. Look | |
| Winthrop C. Rheno | 1926 | R.W. Clarence P. Hayden |
| Erwin C. Burleigh | 1927 | |
| 1928 | Ernest A. Nickel | |
| Charles P. Dunbar | 1929 | |
| 1930 | Roy A. Bunker | |
| Hariph C. Hancock | 1931 | |
| 1932 | Arthur F. Baird | |
| Walter E. Flanders | 1933 | Harold B. Batcheller |
| 1934 | ||
| Walter S. Booker | 1935 | Clyde E. MacNeill |
| 1936 | ||
| William A. Colby | 1937 | R.W. Ludwig Knorr |
| Curtis S. Athearn | 1938 | |
| Joseph C. Allen | 1939 | G. Stanley Garland |
| Elijah W. Crowell | 1940 | |
| R.W. John E. Palmeira | 1941 | Preston H. Morris |
| 1942 | ||
| 1943 | Percy D. West | |
| 1944 | ||
| Theodore C. Howes | 1945 | Arthur E. Rogers |
| 1946 | R.W. George A. Silva | |
| James F. Morris | 1947 | Albert R. Clements |
| James A. Boyle | 1948 | Charles Leighton |
| R.W. S. David Cronig | 1949 | Cyprien P. R. Dube |
| 1950 | Walter E. Bernard | |
| R.W. Lawrence W. Winterbottom | 1951 | Lauress Fisher |
| 1952 | Alfred K. Wilde | |
| E. Everett Howell | 1953 | Ralph E. Grant |
| 1954 | Mansfield D. Grant | |
| Louis M. Greene | 1955 | Trueman A. Place |
| 1956 | Preston W. Averill | |
| William E. Adams | 1957 | Ralph E. Grant |
| Philip V. Cole | 1958 | R.W. Robert E. Cumming |
| 1959 | Preston R. Luce | |
| Robert B. Boren | 1960 | E. Thomas Smith |
| B. Crume Lamb (?) | 1961 | Eugene G. Belisle |
| 1962 | William Hanna | |
| R.W. David L. Welch | 1963 | Robert S. Frasier |
| R.W. A. Douglas Stewart | 1964 | Leo P. Convery |
| 1965 | R.W. Paul M. Chase | |
| 1966 | Frank C. Madeiras | |
| Charles V. Maida | 1967 | Charles M. Lima |
| 1968 | James E. Tripp | |
| R.W. A. Douglas Stewart | 1969 | |
| R. Donald Bermudes | 1970 | R.W. Kenneth W. Deitz |
| 1971 | Peter O. Bettencourt | |
| Ronald H. Tolin | 1972 | |
| Sidney G. White, Jr. | 1973 | R.W. Kenneth W. Deitz |
| David R. Guay | 1974 | James R. Brown |
| 1975 | Forrest F. Felt | |
| Charles V. Maida | 1976 | George R. Luce |
| Sidney G. White, Jr. | 1977 | Thomas A. Durawa |
| Clayton Taylor, Jr. | 1978 | Russell U. Grant |
| 1979 | Preston W. Averill, Jr. | |
| Richard R. Mello | 1980 | Richard P. DeRoche |
| Kenneth Ward | 1981 | |
| James M. Beckman | 1982 | Russell U. Grant |
| R.W. David L. Welch | 1983 | Preston W. Averill, Jr. |
| Richard R. Mello | 1984 | Joseph B. Robichau III |
| R.W. A. Douglas Stewart | 1985 | R.W. Robert C. Corr |
| Arthur J. Bailow | 1986 | Alishan Haigazian |
| 1987 | Michael H. Corr | |
| Christopher Keniston | 1988 | Harold G. Stanley |
| 1989 | Jeffrey C. Corr | |
| James M. Beckman | 1990 | |
| Alfred H. Hopp | 1991 | George G. Martin, Jr. |
| Nathan Hunt | 1992 | Raymond E. Skladzien |
| Leonard P. Reid | 1993 | Mark C. Luce |
| 1994 |
| Oriental-Martha's Vineyard Lodge | |
|---|---|
| 1994 | Frank G. Gibson |
| 1995 | Leo P. Convery, Jr.
(George N. Goulart, Sr., Honorary) |
| 1996 | John R. Tucker |
| 1997 | George H. Fisher, Jr. |
| 1998 | Alan B. Reekie |
| 1999 | |
| 2000 | David W. Roberts |
| 2001 | R. Samuel Carroll |
| 2002 | Richard L. Crawford (D) ⇒ Alan B. Reekie (SW, Acting Master) |
| 2003 | Alan B. Reekie |
| 2004 | Christopher A. Knowles |
| 2005 | Erik G. Blake |
| 2006 | James T. Morse |
| 2007 | |
| 2008 | Leonard R. Verville |
| 2009 | Bruce E. Nevin |
| 2010 | Colin M. Ouderkirk |
| 2011 | Jeffrey S. Baker |
Created on ... June 23, 2008