
| 1859 - UD - Edwin L. Knight | 1859 - Edwin L. Knight | 1860 - Jacob Bickhart |
| 1861 - Edward L. Knight | 1862 - Edward L. Knight | 1863 - Edward L. Knight |
| 1864 - Elias Zimmerman | 1865 - Elias Zimmerman | 1866 - John W. Hollopeter |
| 1867 - Elias Zimmerman | 1868 - Elias Zimmerman | 1869 - Elias Zimmerman |
| 1870 - Elias Zimmerman | 1871 - Elias Zimmerman | 1872 - Edgar Kemp |
| 1873 - Elias Zimmerman | 1874 - Edgar Kemp | 1875 - Elias Zimmerman |
| 1876 - William G. Hollopeter | 1877 - William G. Hollopeter | 1878 - John W. Hollopeter |
| 1879 - E. C. Godfrey | 1880 - E. C. Godfrey | 1881 - John W. Hollopeter |
| 1882 - Charles E. Godfrey | 1883 - John W. Hollopeter | 1884 - Charles A. Godfrey |
| 1885 - Charles E. Godfrey | 1886 - Christian J. Schlatter | 1887 - Mathias Hollopeter |
| 1888 - Mathias Hollopeter | 1889 - Christian J. Schlatter | 1890 - Mathias Hollopeter |
| 1891 - W. Eugene Cook | 1892 - W. Eugene Cook | 1893 - William G. Hollopeter |
| 1894 - William G. Hollopeter | 1895 - William M. DePew | 1896 - Mathias Hollopeter |
| 1897 - Christian J. Schlatter | 1898 - William G. Hollopeter | 1899 -Christian J. Schlatter |
| 1900 - Christian J. Schlatter | 1901 - Elias Zimmerman | 1902 - Christian J. Schlatter |
| 1903 - William W. Maxfield | 1904 - Christian J. Schlatter | 1905 - William G. Hollopeter |
| 1906 - William E. A. DePew | 1907 - William E. A. DePew | 1908 - William E. A. DePew |
| 1909 - John J. Garrett | 1910 - John J. Garrett | 1911 - William M. Dailey |
| 1912 - John J. Garrett | 1913 - Frank C. Kryder | 1914 - John J. Garrett |
| 1915 - William W. Maxfield | 1916 - William W. Maxfield | 1917 -William E. A. DePew |
| 1918 - Frank C. Kryder | 1919 - Arley C. Frederick | 1920 - Harry W. Bender |
| 1921 - William M. Dailey | 1922 - David Lantz | 1923 - Harry W. Bender |
| 1924 - Ernest Conrad | 1925 - Frank Martin | 1926 - Reuben A. Klopfenstein |
| 1927 - Frank A. Bryan Jr. | 1928 - Alvan A. Tharp | 1929 - Henry E. Lantz |
| 1930 - Charles Fletter | 1931 - Albert Lantz | 1932 - E. Keith Wolfe |
| 1933 - Gaylord J. Shank | 1934 - Donald M. Niles | 1935 - Herbert T. Slayton |
| 1936 - W. Leonard Surfus | 1937 - Elga F. Ginder | 1938 - Carl A. Ostermeier |
| 1939 - Edison A. Martin | 1940 - Harry E. Stahr | 1941 - Wilson W. Houser |
| 1942 - Edward G. Taylor | 1943 - Lawrence E. Michael | 1944 - Dean E. Shaffer |
| 1945 - Clifford W. Ostermeier | 1946 - Wilmer E Rediger | 1947 - J. Ray Snyder |
| 1948 - Ray D. Moore | 1949 - Charles E. Smead | 1950 - Harold D. Rediger |
| 1951 - Glenn S. Myers | 1952 - Duane F. Shidler | 1953 - Wendall E. Black |
| 1954 - Robert F. Enslen | 1955 - John M. Bireley | 1956 - Robert A. Tharp |
| 1957 - Leonard B. Fletter | 1958 - Wier W. Anderson | 1959 - Michael J. Bohen |
| 1960 - Wayne M. Rosselet | 1961 - Richard W. Worman | 1962 - Jack V. Bridges |
| 1963 - Arthur J. Popp | 1964 - Joe A. Blough | 1965 - Harold L. J. Shie |
| 1966 - Paul E. Dunn | 1967 - Robert R. Morris | 1968 - Garl E. Miles |
| 1969 - Byron W. Fleming | 1970 - G. Edward Hager | 1971 - Melvin C. Stuart |
| 1972 - Byron Weilbaker | 1973 - John W. Anderson | 1974 - Fred M. Little |
| 1976 - Clarence E. Brown | 1977 - Clarence E. Brown | 1978 - Garl E. Miles |
| 1979 - Richard W. Worman | 1980 - Charles F. Prewett | 1981 - Richard W. Worman |
| 1982 - G.Edward Hager | 1983 - Dennis W. Worman | 1984 - Charles F. Prewett |
| 1985 - Malcolm E. Bender | 1986 - James V. Smith | 1987 - Jon T. Douglas Sr. |
| 1988 - Jerry L. McDaniel | 1989 - Charles M. Bohen | 1990 - Ralph R. Hill |
| 1991 - Larry L. Schlatter | 1992 - John S. Arford | 1993 - Douglas R. Hill |
| 1994 - Mark A. Sites | 1995 - Terry L. Hill | 1996 - Gary D. Reece |
| 1997 - Charles M. Bohen | 1998 - Kenneth A. Hill | 1999 - Richard A. Brown |
| 2000 - Ronald D. Rhonemus | 2001 - Stanley G. Bloom | 2002 - Richard A. Brown |
| 2003 - Richard A. Brown | 2004 - Jack L. Koch | 2005 - Ernie Longberry |
| 2006 - Ernie Longberry | 2007 - Richard A. Brown | 2008 |
| 2009 | 2010 | 2011 |
Past Masters 1863 - Consolidation with Leo Lodge
| 1863 - J. S. Crisenbury | 1864 - J. S. Crisenbury | 1865 - Ira S. Skinner |
| 1866 - Ira S. Skinner | 1867 - J. S. Crisenbury | 1868 - J. S. Crisenbury |
| 1889 - J. S. Crisenbury | 1870 - L. C. Coomer | 1871 - L. C. Coomer |
| 1872 - L. C. Coomer | 1873 - L. C. Coomer | 1874 - L. C. Coomer |
| 1875 - L. C. Coomer | 1876 - L. C. Coomer | 1877 - L. C. Coomer |
| 1878 - L. C. Coomer | 1879 - L. C. Coomer | 1880 - L. C. Coomer |
| 1881 - John Stephen | 1882 - L. C. Coomer | 1883 - John Stephen |
| 1884 - John Stephen | 1885 - John Stephen | 1886 - John Stephen |
| 1887 - W. I. Hayes | 1888 - Jabes Schaffer | 1889 - John Stephen |
| 1890 - W. I. Hayes | 1891 - Robert Murphy | 1892 - Robert Murphy |
| 1893 - John Stephen | 1894 - William Overhelter | 1995 - Robert Murphy |
| 1896 - James Nuttle | 1897 - John Stephen | 1898 - John Stephen |
| 1899 - John Stephen | 1900 - | 1901 - |
| 1902 - | 1903 - | 1904 - |
| 1905 - Robert Murphy | 1906 - | 1907 - |
| 1908 - William Vallieu | 1909 - Ira C. Grubb | 1910 - W. B. Reichelderfer |
| 1911 - Joseph Ringwalt | 1912 - Wilson H. Thompson | 1913 - Ray Knisley |
| 1914 - D. D. Boston | 1915 - Oliver O. Knisley | 1916 - William Vallieu |
| 1917 - Edward D. Brandom | 1818 - Craton W. Darling | 1919 - William Sheppelman |
| 1920 - Jacob C. Amstutz | 1921 - A. M. Amstutz | 1922 - Harley Werley |
| 1923 - William Harter | 1924 - J. C. Emme | 1925 - Mark T. Lipsett |
| 1926 - Charles Stranger | 1927 - Jacob C. Amstutz | 1928 - William Vallieu |
| 1929 - Leroy Timbrook | 1930 - Leroy Timbrook | 1931 - Oliver O. Knisley |
| 1932 - Oliver O. Knisley | 1933 - Albert Chausse | 1934 - George Roller |
| 1935 - Oliver O. Knisley | 1936 - DeGroff Schwartz | 1937 - Oliver O. Knisley |
| 1938 - Kenneth Amstutz | 1939 - Herman Deister | 1940 - Lester Smith |
| 1941 - Donald Irving | 1942 - Wilber Koch | 1943 - Orville Delong |
| 1944 - Harold Egler | 1945 - David A. Bartle Jr. | 1946 - Richard R. Harris |
| 1947 - Paul Clifford Gorrell | 1948 - Dewitt Volkert | 1949 - George Koch |
| 1950 - Richard L. Stauffer | 1951 - Hanly J. Gorrell | 1952 - Zenns U. Brandom |
| 1953 - Carl W. Roberts | 1954 - Ralph I. Rogers | 1955 - Otho E. Gustin |
| 1956 - Jack Dean Lineberry | 1957 - Frank E. Love | 1958 - Robert G. Hissong |
| 1959 - Kenneth C. Stotler | 1960 - Harry A. Wann | 1961 - Walter L. Love |
| 1962 - Cyrus D. Gustin | 1963 - Rolland E. Johnson | 1964 - Alfred Moore |
| 1965 - Lynn H. Smith | 1966 - Stanley L. Love | 1967 - Roland S. Dorsey |
| 1968 - Elmer D. Strautman | 1969 - Lester Luttrell | 1970 - Ronald Smith |
| 1971 - Kenneth James | 1972 - Max A. James | 1973 - Keith Pierson |
| 1974 - Gilbert L. Smith | 1975 - Donald Hertig | 1976 - Clarence Poisel |
| 1977 - Clarence Poisel | 1978 - Walter W. Love | 1979 - Kenneth C. Stotler |
| 1980 - Kenneth C. Stotler | 1981 - Dennis W. Lake | 1982 - Howard D. Amstutz |
| 1983 - Ronald Reddin | 1984 - Dennis W. Lake | 1985 - Jack L. Koch |
| 1986 - Jack L. Koch | 1987 - Jack L. Koch | 1988 - Jack L. Fielitz |
| 1989 - Kenneth R. Stotler | 1990 - | 1991 - David R. Hieber |
| 1992 - Dean K. Gerbers | 1993 - Shane O. Ulmer | 1994 - |
| 1995 - Jack L. Koch | 1996 - Pat E. Harris | 1997 - Jack L. Koch |
| 1998 - Jack L. Koch | 1999 - Gilbert L. Smith | 2000 - Gilbert L. Smith |