| 1895 (UD) – Charles Day | 1935 – T. Jeff Tuttle | 1975 – *Douglas Horsfield | 2015 – *V. Joey Gregory |
| 1896 – Charles Day | 1936 – Theo Gilbert | 1976 – *Kenneth R. Arterburn | 2016 – *Sam Rush |
| 1897 – Silas W. Hodge | 1937 – Theo Gilbert | 1977 – *Dennis Coffey | 2017 – *Ralph D. Spurlock |
| 1898 – J. J. Jones | 1938 – Theo Gilbert | 1978 – Lowry Sibert | 2018 – |
| 1899 – John C. Jones | 1939 – Foster C. Brock | 1979 – *Roger Whitaker | 2019 – |
| 1900 – Simon S. Phillips | 1940 – Foster C. Brock | 1980 – *Roger Whitaker | 2020 – |
| 1901 – G. W. Watkins | 1941 – T. Jeff Tuttle | 1981 – *Dennis Coffey | 2021 – |
| 1902 – G. S. Brock | 1942 – T. Jeff Tuttle | 1982 – Lowry Sibert | 2022 – |
| 1903 – John C. Jones | 1943 – Taylor Sasser | 1983 – Oakley W. Caudill | 2023 – |
| 1904 – Charles Day | 1944 – Taylor Sasser | 1984 – Fred Williams | 2024 – |
| 1905 – Simon S. Phillips | 1945 – Taylor Sasser | 1985 – *Phillip E. Barnard | 2025 – |
| 1906 – John C. Jones | 1946 – Theo Gilbert | 1986 – T. A. Schell | 2026 – |
| 1907 – James M. Brock | 1947 – Emanuel Taylor | 1987 – Preston Collier | 2027 – |
| 1908 – Simon S. Phillips | 1948 – George Sasser | 1988 – *Phillip E. Barnard | 2028 – |
| 1909 – William Johnson | 1949 – George Sasser | 1989 – *David Hibbitts | 2029 – |
| 1910 – John A. Tuttle | 1950 – Oakley B. Cobb | 1990 – Herman Gray | 2030 – |
| 1911 – William Martin | 1951 – Franklin Reynolds | 1991 – *Dale Wyatt | |
| 1912 – Simon S. Phillips | 1952 – Luther Gilbert | 1992 – *David Hibbitts | |
| 1913 – Charles Day | 1953 – Troy Fields | 1993 – *Terry Amburgey | |
| 1914 – William Martin | 1954 – Fred Williams | 1994 – *Terry Holbrook | |
| 1915 – G. W. Beets | 1955 – Denvis Rush | 1995 – *Billy Gregory | |
| 1916 – J. N. Williams | 1956 – Alfred Peters | 1996 – Vincent Ivey | |
| 1917 – Virgil Vandeventer | 1957 – Clark Jones | 1997 – *Lynn Fields | |
| 1918 – John C. Jones | 1958 – Lowell Gilbert | 1998 – *Jack Binder | |
| 1919 – John C. Jones | 1959 – Winfred Lewis | 1999 – *David Hibbitts | |
| 1920 – Charles Day | 1960 – Delford Walden | 2000 – *Phillip E. Barnard | |
| 1921 – T. Jeff Tuttle | 1961 – Stanley Hendrix | 2001 – Phillip Gilbert | |
| 1922 – T. Jeff Tuttle | 1962 – Troy Fields | 2002 – *David Martin Young | |
| 1923 – F. R. Brock | 1963 – R. Gay Blair | 2003 – Charles R. Webb | |
| 1924 – Taylor Sasser | 1964 – John Peters | 2004 – *John Smith | |
| 1925 – Taylor Sasser | 1965 – Franklin Reynolds | 2005 – *Tim Williams | |
| 1926 – John A. Tuttle | 1966 – Charlie Taylor | 2006 – *Anthony Pennington | |
| 1927 – Herbert Hinkle | 1967 – Ishmael Horsfield | 2007 – *Mike Smith | |
| 1928 – John England | 1968 – George Bruner | 2008 – *Gary Fleming | |
| 1929 – W. J. Watkins | 1969 – *Joe Swafford | 2009 – *James Black | |
| 1930 – W. J. Watkins | 1970 – *Kenneth R. Arterburn | 2010 – *Jason Bolton | |
| 1931 – Foster C. Brock | 1971 – *Johnnie Brock, Jr. | 2011 – *Kevin Gregory | |
| 1932 – Foster C. Brock | 1972 – Sam Grigsby | 2012 – *Brandon Durham | |
| 1933 – Foster C. Brock | 1973 – Rupert Rush | 2013 – *Gregory A. Lay | |
| 1934 – Foster C. Brock | 1974 – Warren Allen | 2014 – *Roger Rush | |
| * Still Living |