| 1962 | Silas T. Dixon |
| 1968 | James H. Houston |
| 1969 | Doyle G. Rambo |
| 1970 | Alfred M. Spry |
| 1974 | Robert R. Lipinski, (Allapattah #271, Miami, FL) |
| 1975 | Charles D. Brumley |
| 1976 | Howard R. Gabbard |
| 1977 | James L. Butler |
| 1979 | Errol L. Cooper, Jr. |
| 1980 | Robert W. Davenport, P.G.M. |
| 1983 | Leonard E. Coner |
| 1984 | E. Leon Cox |
| 1985 | David A. Boston |
| 1986 | Joseph F. Alexander |
| 1987 | William G. Craycraft |
| 1988 | Ralph E. Blevins |
| 1989 | Ralph D. Campbell |
| 1990 | Charles F. Powell |
| 1990 | John D. Jacobs, (Lexington #1, Lexington, KY) |
| 1992 | Roger D. McBride |
| 1993 | Leonard A. Alexander |
| 1994 | Danny L. Patrick |
| 1995 | James H. Dixon |
| 1996 | Gerald P. McCahren |
| 1997 | Michael R. Visty |
| 1998 | Douglas C. Swiggett |
| 1999 | Alan W. Ray |
| 2000 | Vincent J. Blanch |
| 2001 | Anthony W. Wright |
| 2002 | Derek B. Phelps |
| 2003 | John A. Blanchard, II |
| 2004 | William G. Hiles |